Do schools kill creativity? | Sir Ken Robinson | TED
10258 symboles
7 min de lecture
SUMMARY
Sir Ken Robinson, in his witty 2006 TED Talk, argues that rigid education systems stifle children's innate creativity, urging a reform to nurture diverse talents as vital as literacy for an unpredictable future.
STATEMENTS
- Human creativity shines through the variety and range in TED presentations and attendees, highlighting extraordinary evidence of potential.
- The conference reveals profound uncertainty about the future, making education's role in preparing for it both crucial and challenging.
- Everyone shares a deep personal interest in education, akin to religion or money, as it shapes lives profoundly.
- Children entering school now will retire around 2065, yet no one can predict the world's state, underscoring education's unpredictability.
- All children possess tremendous talents, but societal and educational systems ruthlessly squander them through neglect.
- Creativity deserves equal status to literacy in education, demanding the same priority and respect.
- Young children fearlessly take chances and embrace being wrong, a trait essential for originality that diminishes with age.
- Education systems worldwide stigmatize mistakes, running schools and companies in ways that eliminate creative capacities.
- Public education hierarchies prioritize mathematics and languages over arts, reflecting industrial-era needs rather than human diversity.
- The system produces university professors as the pinnacle of success, ignoring broader forms of intelligence and achievement.
IDEAS
- A six-year-old girl boldly declares she'll draw God so everyone knows what he looks like, showing unfiltered childhood imagination.
- Four-year-olds improvise in a Nativity play, misnaming gifts like "Frank sent this" for myrrh, revealing kids' willingness to experiment without fear.
- Picasso's view that children are born artists but get educated out of creativity flips the narrative on growth and learning.
- Global education hierarchies universally rank math and languages highest, relegating arts like dance to the bottom despite natural human inclinations.
- Schools educate children "from the waist up," focusing on heads and sidelining bodies, producing disembodied academics who treat bodies as mere transport.
- Industrialism birthed modern education to churn out workers, steering kids from passions like music because they "won't get jobs" doing them.
- Academic inflation devalues degrees; today's bachelor's holders compete for jobs needing master's, trapping graduates in limbo.
- Intelligence manifests diversely—visually, aurally, kinesthetically—yet systems favor abstract thinking, marginalizing other modes.
- The brain's corpus callosum, thicker in women, enables superior multitasking, explaining why some handle chaos while others can't fry an egg amid distractions.
- Choreographer Gillian Lynne was nearly medicated for "ADHD" in the 1930s but thrived when recognized as a dancer, leading to hits like "Cats."
- Education strip-mines minds for academic commodities, akin to environmental exploitation, unsustainable for future human ecology.
- Jonas Salk's insight that human disappearance would let life flourish in 50 years, unlike insects' extinction, underscores humanity's disruptive potential.
INSIGHTS
- Rigid education hierarchies suppress innate creativity by prioritizing error-free academics over risk-taking and diverse expression.
- Children's fearless experimentation fosters originality, but societal stigma against mistakes systematically erodes this vital capacity.
- Industrial-era schooling designed for conformity ignores intelligence's diversity, dynamism, and distinctiveness, limiting human potential.
- Recognizing talents through holistic observation, as in Gillian Lynne's case, unlocks extraordinary achievements over pathologizing differences.
- Future unpredictability demands educating the whole child—body, mind, and imagination—to navigate technological and demographic shifts.
- Reconstituting human ecology in education means valuing creative capacities as richly as environmental balance for sustainable flourishing.
QUOTES
- "I'm drawing a picture of God." / "But nobody knows what God looks like." / "They will in a minute."
- "If you're not prepared to be wrong, you'll never come up with anything original."
- "All children are born artists. The problem is to remain an artist as we grow up."
- "Mrs. Lynne, Gillian isn't sick. She's a dancer. Take her to a dance school."
- "If all the insects were to disappear from the Earth, within 50 years, all life on Earth would end. If all human beings disappeared from the Earth, within 50 years, all forms of life would flourish."
HABITS
- Children naturally dance and move constantly when permitted, integrating physical expression into daily life for better thinking.
- Young kids habitually take risks and try things without knowing outcomes, embracing uncertainty as a path to discovery.
- Encouraging fidgeting and movement in learning environments, as in dance classes, helps those who think through motion rather than sitting still.
- Adults in creative fields, like choreographers, sustain childhood patterns of responding to music and rhythm instinctively.
- Multitasking fluidly, as observed in women juggling tasks, mirrors how integrated brain functions support dynamic intelligence in practice.
FACTS
- Children starting school in 2006 will retire around 2065, facing a world impossible to predict despite expert insights.
- UNESCO projects more people will graduate worldwide in the next 30 years than in all prior human history combined.
- No widespread public education systems existed before the 19th century; they emerged to serve industrial workforce needs.
- The brain's corpus callosum, connecting hemispheres, is thicker in women, facilitating enhanced multitasking abilities.
- In the 1930s, conditions like ADHD weren't recognized, leading to misdiagnoses of natural behaviors like fidgeting as disorders.
REFERENCES
- Picasso's quote on children as born artists.
- Shakespeare's birthplace in Snitterfield, near Stratford-on-Avon.
- Gillian Lynne's choreography for "Cats" and "Phantom of the Opera."
- Jonas Salk's ecological comparison of humans and insects.
HOW TO APPLY
- Elevate creativity in curricula by assigning it the same daily time and resources as core subjects like mathematics.
- Foster risk-taking in classrooms by reframing mistakes as essential steps toward innovation, not failures to punish.
- Assess intelligence through multiple modes—visual, kinesthetic, auditory—rather than solely academic tests.
- Introduce mandatory arts and physical activities, such as daily dance, to engage the whole body and mind equally.
- Identify individual talents early via observation in varied settings, directing children to specialized environments like dance schools.
ONE-SENTENCE TAKEAWAY
Reform education to nurture children's diverse creative talents as urgently as literacy for an unpredictable future.
RECOMMENDATIONS
- Dismantle subject hierarchies to value arts and dance equally with math, preventing the marginalization of bodily intelligences.
- Create mistake-tolerant learning cultures that celebrate experimentation, reversing the fear instilled by current systems.
- Redesign assessments for diverse intelligences, incorporating visual, kinesthetic, and interactive evaluations beyond academics.
- Invest in holistic talent discovery programs, observing children in dynamic settings to uncover hidden gifts like Gillian Lynne's.
- Shift toward interdisciplinary education that sparks creativity through blending disciplines, preparing for technological revolutions.
MEMO
In a packed TED auditorium in 2006, British educator Sir Ken Robinson captivated the audience with a humorous yet urgent plea: schools are killing creativity. Drawing from conference themes of human innovation and future uncertainty, Robinson argued that education, meant to guide children into an unknowable world—they'll retire in 2065—fails by squandering innate talents. "All kids have tremendous talents, and we squander them, pretty ruthlessly," he declared, using anecdotes like a six-year-old girl's defiant drawing of God to illustrate children's fearless imagination.
Robinson dissected the global education hierarchy, where mathematics and languages reign supreme while arts languish at the bottom. This structure, born of 19th-century industrialism, steers children away from passions deemed unemployable, producing a narrow elite of university professors who embody "disembodied" intellect. He quipped about academics treating their bodies as mere vehicles for heads, evoking laughter with visions of professors awkwardly dancing at conferences. Yet beneath the wit lies a profound critique: by stigmatizing mistakes and educating "from the waist up," systems rob society of diverse geniuses, from visual thinkers to kinesthetic movers.
A pivotal story spotlighted choreographer Gillian Lynne, nearly labeled disordered in the 1930s for fidgeting—today's ADHD—but saved when a doctor played music, revealing her as a dancer. She went on to create "Cats" and "Phantom of the Opera," enriching millions. Robinson contrasted this with academic inflation, where degrees lose value amid population booms and tech shifts; UNESCO predicts more graduates in 30 years than ever before. Intelligence, he insisted, is diverse (thinking in images or movement), dynamic (brain interactions fueling originality), and distinct—qualities the system ignores.
Ultimately, Robinson called for a "human ecology" revolution, akin to Rachel Carson's environmental awakening. Education must mine minds sustainably, not strip-like the earth, recognizing creativity's value equal to literacy. Quoting Jonas Salk, he warned of humanity's fragility: without insects, life ends; without humans, it flourishes. TED celebrates imagination, he said, but we must wield it wisely to empower children for tomorrow.
As applause thundered, Robinson's message resonated: our task is to educate whole beings—body, mind, spirit—so they shape a thriving future we may not see. In an era of AI and global change, his vision challenges us to reclaim creativity as humanity's greatest gift.