Tucker Carlson on the Israel First Meltdown and the Future of the America First Movement

    Nov 13, 2025

    19531 символов

    13 мин. чтения

    SUMMARY

    Tucker Carlson critiques the right's infighting over Israel support, featuring Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro's rhetoric, and interviews Ana Kasparian on America-First priorities, anti-Semitism smears, and rejecting divisive politics.

    STATEMENTS

    • The ongoing fight on the right about Nazis and platforming began behind the scenes in January after Trump's inauguration.
    • Benjamin Netanyahu visited the White House to secure American support for a regime change war against Iran.
    • Israel views Iran as its primary regional threat due to conventional weapons and potential nuclear capabilities.
    • Israel could not sustain a war against Iran alone without U.S. military involvement.
    • The debate centers on whether U.S. interests align with Israel's push for regime change in Iran.
    • Proponents of the war framed opposition as anti-Semitism to avoid substantive debate.
    • Carlson and Charlie Kirk were among the few to directly urge Trump against involvement in an Iran war.
    • The U.S. committed military force to Iran in June but avoided full regime change.
    • The real debate is about U.S. government serving its citizens first in a representative democracy.
    • Trump's election was based on promises to prioritize America's domestic issues.
    • The institutional right has embraced identity politics and censorship, contradicting prior stances.
    • Mark Levin accuses critics of Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, Megyn Kelly, and Steve Bannon of being Jew-hating thugs.
    • Levin invokes historical enemies like Babylonians, Persians, Romans, and Hitler to defend Israel.
    • Levin's rhetoric inverts the debate, portraying opponents as seeking to kill Jews.
    • Levin's attacks are personal and ad hominem, filled with hate that can infect listeners.
    • Carlson apologizes for his vicious remarks about Liz Cheney, recognizing the trap of becoming hateful.
    • The fight is internal, against one's own inclination to mirror hateful figures like Levin.
    • Levin justifies civilian deaths in Gaza as collateral damage, rejecting crocodile tears for Palestinians.
    • Levin's views endorse blood guilt, collective punishment, and genocide based on birth.
    • Western principles reject blood guilt and collective punishment, lessons from World War II.
    • Levin claims anti-Semitism is in critics' DNA, contradicting individual judgment.
    • Levin's Nazi labels incite violence, as seen in his post-assassination comments on Charlie Kirk.
    • Levin refuses to debate Nazis, extending the label to Carlson and others.
    • The right's sudden embrace of censorship contradicts its anti-woke platform.
    • Priorities should focus on American issues like health insurance and debt, not foreign lobbies.
    • Ben Shapiro dismisses Venezuela's social conservatism under Maduro, prioritizing anti-communism.
    • Shapiro shows contempt for Americans unable to afford living in their hometowns.
    • Retirement at 65 is deemed insane by Shapiro, ignoring physical labor realities.
    • Leadership requires love for the people led, which neoconservatives lack.
    • There are no permanent enemies; reconciliation brings profound joy.
    • Ana Kasparian apologizes for smearing Aaron Maté over Syria reporting.
    • Partisan divides are manufactured to distract from government neglect of Americans.
    • Criticism of Israel provokes violence and job threats against critics like Kasparian.
    • U.S. alliances should prioritize national security, not endless foreign aid.

    IDEAS

    • Infighting on the right masks a deeper clash between America-First and Israel-First priorities.
    • Netanyahu's visit exploited Trump's inauguration to push U.S. into an Iran war.
    • Framing foreign policy debates as anti-Semitism silences legitimate U.S. interest discussions.
    • Regime change wars benefit Israel but drain U.S. resources without reciprocal gains.
    • Historical lessons from Iraq show regime change harms America, yet they're ignored.
    • Christians' universalist beliefs make anti-Semitism incompatible with sincere faith.
    • Trump's election rejected foreign entanglements for domestic revival.
    • Institutional conservatives have flipped to identity politics, betraying anti-woke rhetoric.
    • Levin's rants personalize debates, turning policy into character assassination.
    • Hateful rhetoric risks turning responders into mirrors of the aggressor.
    • Apologizing publicly preserves integrity and prevents moral erosion.
    • Blood guilt ideology revives genocidal thinking rejected post-World War II.
    • DNA-based judgments echo Nazi and Soviet atrocities against groups.
    • Labeling critics Nazis deters debate and incites violence predictably.
    • Foreign lobbies like AIPAC should register transparently to avoid subversion.
    • Personal priorities, like health costs or usury caps, outweigh imposed foreign threats.
    • Shapiro's dismissal of social issues reveals prioritizing economics over human dignity.
    • High-interest debt enslaves the poor, blocking family formation and homeownership.
    • Contempt for working-class Americans undermines conservative leadership claims.
    • Universalism fosters national unity against tribal divisions.
    • Reconciliation with former opponents yields life's deepest joys.
    • Manufactured partisanship distracts from shared American struggles.
    • Smears against Israel critics breed real anti-Semitism through backlash.
    • 9/11's legacy includes civil liberty losses and endless Middle East wars.
    • Economic surpluses pre-9/11 turned to $38 trillion debt from foreign aid and conflicts.
    • Aligning across aisles on foreign policy could reform two-party failures.

    INSIGHTS

    • Debates on foreign policy succeed when focused on national interests, not ethnic loyalties.
    • Weaponizing anti-Semitism accusations evades accountability for war advocacy.
    • Internal self-control against hate preserves moral superiority in conflicts.
    • Rejecting blood guilt upholds Western individualism over collective damnation.
    • Leadership devoid of empathy for citizens erodes democratic legitimacy.
    • Apologies for past errors build credibility and national reconciliation.
    • High usury rates perpetuate debt slavery, hindering societal flourishing.
    • Manufactured foreign threats divert from domestic economic crises.
    • Universalist identities counter tribalism's divisive pull.
    • Censorship by supposed free speech advocates reveals hypocrisy.
    • Prioritizing reconciliation over enmity enables personal and societal growth.
    • Post-9/11 policies enriched foreign agendas at America's expense.
    • Cross-partisan alliances on core issues like non-interventionism strengthen democracy.
    • Contempt for the working class alienates potential conservative support.
    • Economic metrics like GDP ignore spiritual and communal well-being.
    • Incendiary labels accelerate violence cycles, demanding rhetorical restraint.
    • Shared American identity transcends ethnic or partisan fractures.

    QUOTES

    • "The real battle isn’t with Mark Levin. The real battle is not to become Mark Levin."
    • "Is it in America's interest to participate in that war? And make no mistake, Israel wouldn't last 3 days in a war by itself against Iran."
    • "Why do you hate the Jews? You're a Nazi."
    • "The government is not representing its own citizens, if it doesn't care about its own citizens, it's not only off track, it's illegitimate."
    • "Since when did those people become completely committed to identity politics and censorship?"
    • "You think your puny little asses are going to be able to do it? Kill the Jews."
    • "Hate is absolutely real. And if you listen to enough Mark Levin, you yourself can become hateful."
    • "I'm sorry to Liz Cheney. And I mean that, too."
    • "You should be killed by virtue of who your parents are, who your grandparents were."
    • "Guilt or virtue are not in your DNA. We don't believe in a chosen people and we don't believe in a damned people."
    • "I don't debate the Klan. I don't debate Nazis."
    • "Who gives a whether he's anti-LGBTQ rights? Who gives a"
    • "If you are a young person and you can't afford to live here, then maybe you should not live here."
    • "No one in the United States should be retiring at 65 years old."
    • "Don't become the people you despise, or else what's the point?"
    • "There's no greater joy than the joy of reconciliation."
    • "Don't let them win when they do that to you because you know in your heart you're not an anti-semite."
    • "Do not become what you claim to hate."
    • "This type of behavior is exactly what leads to anti-semitism."
    • "Our priority should be here at home."

    HABITS

    • Wake up daily checking for right-wing infighting updates on social media.
    • Engage in behind-the-scenes policy advocacy like visiting the White House.
    • Publicly apologize for personal attacks to maintain integrity.
    • Reflect on hateful impulses to avoid mirroring aggressors.
    • Prioritize universalist thinking in Christian practice.
    • Debate U.S. interests openly without ethnic framing.
    • Consume media critically to resist infectious hate.
    • Journal daily to track personal changes over time.
    • Focus discussions on domestic issues like health costs.
    • Lead with empathy in leadership roles.
    • Apologize unequivocally for past smears in media.
    • Reject divisive rhetoric in favor of humanity-focused debate.
    • Align across partisanship on shared priorities.
    • Challenge systemic economic barriers personally.
    • Practice restraint in inflammatory online exchanges.
    • Celebrate reconciliation in relationships.
    • Admit faults publicly to build credibility.
    • Prioritize family and community ties in decisions.

    FACTS

    • Trump's inauguration was on January 22nd this year.
    • Netanyahu congratulated Biden first after 2020 election.
    • U.S. bombed Iran in June, spending billions on Israel's protection.
    • Iraq regime change was Israel-inspired.
    • Christians view all people as capable of salvation through Jesus.
    • Hitler died 80 years ago in April.
    • U.S. has 350 million people.
    • Babylonians, Persians, Romans failed to eliminate Jews.
    • Gaza has 2 million Palestinians.
    • U.S. fought Third Reich without sparing civilians entirely.
    • World War II consensus rejected blood guilt post-Nazis.
    • Soviets committed genocide against Christians efficiently.
    • U.S. federal debt is $38 trillion.
    • $30 billion U.S. aid to Israel since October 7th.
    • Average U.S. homebuyer age rose from 28 to nearly 40.
    • 63 million U.S. abortions since Roe v. Wade.
    • 100,000 annual U.S. drug overdose deaths.
    • 9/11 killed 3,000 Americans.
    • U.S. had economic surplus at Bush administration start.
    • Iran notified U.S. before missile strikes near air base.

    REFERENCES

    • Donald Trump's inauguration and platform.
    • Benjamin Netanyahu's White House visit.
    • Joe Biden's 2020 election congratulations.
    • Iran regime change war proposal.
    • Iraq War as regime change example.
    • Charlie Kirk's White House advocacy.
    • Mark Levin's radio/TV shows and Twitter posts.
    • Dick Cheney and Liz Cheney's public roles.
    • BLM movement.
    • Me Too movement.
    • COVID pandemic.
    • Joseph Stalin and World War II alliances.
    • Nazi regime and Holocaust.
    • Soviet genocides against Christians.
    • Deuteronomy's Amalek description.
    • Dietrich Bonhoeffer's life and writings.
    • Prodigal Son biblical story.
    • Aaron Maté's Syria and Gaza journalism.
    • The Young Turks (TYT) show.
    • Pierce Morgan's panel discussions.
    • Aaron Maté's X posts.
    • Canary Mission organization.
    • Stop Anti-Semitism group.
    • Jews in School group.
    • Barry Weiss's interviews.
    • John Fetterman Senate role.
    • 9/11 Files episodes by Tucker Carlson.
    • Eight Sleep Pod 5 product.
    • Landman series on Paramount+.
    • PureTalk wireless service.
    • Canines for Warriors veteran organization.

    HOW TO APPLY

    • Identify underlying foreign policy motives in early political engagements.
    • Assess alignment of U.S. interests before committing to international conflicts.
    • Reframe smear-driven debates to focus on national priorities.
    • Advocate directly to leaders against unwanted wars.
    • Recognize intimidation tactics like anti-Semitism accusations.
    • Maintain universalist principles in faith-based discussions.
    • Prioritize domestic issues in election platforms.
    • Counter identity politics with arguments for citizen representation.
    • Analyze personal attacks for hate content and respond calmly.
    • Apologize sincerely for inflammatory statements immediately.
    • Reflect on emotional triggers to prevent hateful mimicry.
    • Justify civilian protections in conflict rhetoric.
    • Reject blood guilt narratives in policy advocacy.
    • Promote individual accountability over genetic judgments.
    • Use labels like Nazi sparingly to avoid inciting violence.
    • Defend free speech consistently across ideologies.
    • Focus personal priorities on tangible American problems.
    • Critique economic exploitation like high-interest loans publicly.
    • Build cross-partisan coalitions on foreign policy restraint.
    • Practice public remorse to model accountability.
    • Challenge systemic barriers affecting youth and families.
    • Foster reconciliation by acknowledging shared humanity.
    • Resist manufactured divisions through optimistic dialogue.
    • Document and report organized smear campaigns.
    • Demand transparency from foreign lobbies.
    • Evaluate leadership by empathy for constituents.
    • Reject permanent enmities in relationships.
    • Align actions with America-First universalism.
    • Question post-9/11 policies' long-term costs.

    ONE-SENTENCE TAKEAWAY

    Prioritize America-First policies and reject divisive smears to foster unity and avoid internal violence.

    RECOMMENDATIONS

    • Debate foreign policy based on U.S. benefits, not loyalty accusations.
    • Apologize publicly for past errors to build trust.
    • Resist hateful rhetoric to prevent personal moral decay.
    • Focus media on domestic crises like debt and healthcare.
    • Challenge high usury rates to alleviate poor's burdens.
    • Reject blood guilt ideologies in all discussions.
    • Promote universalism to counter tribal divisions.
    • Demand AIPAC registers as foreign lobby.
    • Critique leaders lacking empathy for citizens.
    • Align across parties on non-interventionism.
    • Document smears and report organized harassment.
    • Prioritize reconciliation over permanent enmities.
    • Question 9/11 policy legacies critically.
    • Advocate for economic reforms aiding family formation.
    • Maintain free speech defenses universally.
    • Model humanity in fiery debates.
    • Reject retirement age impositions ignoring labor realities.
    • Foster national identity over ethnic cliques.
    • Limit foreign aid to direct security threats.
    • Celebrate cross-ideological dialogues for progress.

    MEMO

    Tucker Carlson dissects the escalating infighting on the American right, tracing its roots not to recent podcast controversies but to January's shadows following Donald Trump's inauguration. As Benjamin Netanyahu became the first foreign leader to visit the White House, his agenda crystallized: securing U.S. backing for regime change in Iran, Israel's paramount regional foe armed with missiles and nuclear ambitions. Carlson argues this sparked a covert battle between America-First advocates wary of another Middle East quagmire—like Iraq—and Israel-First proponents who reframed dissent as anti-Semitism, stifling open debate on whether U.S. blood and treasure should serve foreign ends.

    The monologue exposes how war hawks evaded substance by invoking Nazis and Jewish hatred, a tactic Carlson says intimidates critics into silence. He and Charlie Kirk alone confronted Trump directly, warning against luring America into conflict under false pretenses like nuclear denial. Though U.S. strikes hit Iran in June without full invasion, the bitterness endures, with figures like Mark Levin amplifying hysteria. Levin, once obscure, now rants about "Jew-hating thugs" from Babylon to Hitler, inverting arguments to accuse opponents of genocide while endorsing Gaza's civilian deaths as inevitable collateral. Carlson warns Levin's hate risks infecting listeners, recounting his own remorseful apology for viciously slandering Liz Cheney amid emotional fury.

    At the heart lies a betrayal of conservative principles: the institutional right, once anti-woke warriors against identity politics and censorship, now wields them ruthlessly. Carlson likens the frenzy to BLM or Me Too—moral panics diverting from crises like America's decay. Levin's blood guilt rhetoric, deeming Palestinians damned by birth, revives Nazi-like horrors rejected after World War II. Carlson rejects DNA-based evil, insisting Western universalism judges individuals, not groups—a bulwark against genocide's return. Labeling critics Nazis, Levin incites violence, as seen post-Charlie Kirk's assassination, yet refuses debate, branding even Carlson one.

    Ben Shapiro embodies this elite disconnect, dismissing Venezuela's social conservatism under Maduro—bans on abortion, porn, and usury—as irrelevant beside communism. Carlson probes deeper: Shapiro's contempt shines in urging young Americans to flee unaffordable hometowns and scorning retirement at 65, ignoring blue-collar aches. This reveals a worldview prizing GDP over souls, foreign allies over citizens—Shapiro once mused Netanyahu for U.S. president. Such attitudes, Carlson says, demand censorship to thrive, as free markets reject leaders without love for the led. Patriarchy models good governance on paternal care; neocons fail here, treating people as cattle.

    The discussion pivots to unity's imperative. There are no Amalekites—irredeemable foes—only changeable humans. Reconciliation's joy, like the Prodigal Son's, counters enmity's trap. Carlson praises Ana Kasparian, once a left-wing foe, for her America-First clarity and public apology to journalist Aaron Maté for a five-year-old Syria smear. Kasparian echoes: reject smears, see humanity across divides. Partisanship's manufactured; shared struggles demand focus. Her critique of Israel draws violence—neighborhood assaults, job threats to her apolitical husband—yet she vows never to let it breed anti-Semitism, blaming such tactics for its rise.

    Kasparian's ordeal underscores the peril: shadowy groups like Canary Mission harass critics, conflating policy dissent with hatred. She recounts a dog attack incited by "Jew hater" slurs, revealing organized sabotage. Yet optimism glimmers—Americans tire of funding Israel's expansions while drowning in $38 trillion debt from post-9/11 wars. 9/11's ghosts haunt: civil liberties lost, surpluses squandered on Iraq, now al-Qaeda figures like Ahmed al-Shara hobnobbing at the White House. Kasparian blasts hypocrisy—real terrorism forgiven if Israel-aligned, while critics face jihadist labels.

    Economically, the alliance crushes: $30 billion to Israel since October 7th for Gaza atrocities, trumping Social Security's strains. Carlson and Kasparian decry usury's slavery—600% payday loans trapping youth in debt, delaying homes and families. Average homebuyers now near 40, not 28 as in 1980s. Shapiro's retorts expose priorities: foreign handouts unquestioned, domestic pleas "entitlement." Carlson urges systemic blame alongside self-reflection—tax codes and hiring rules bind individuals.

    Ultimately, convergence looms: Trump’s win repudiated foreign obsessions for home focus. Kasparian envisions alliances beyond parties, prioritizing citizens over endless aid. Carlson agrees—admit Iraq's folly to avoid Iran's; reject tribalism for American identity. In a fracturing nation, universalism binds: control behavior, apologize faults, debate fiercely but humanely. As violence brews from smears, leading by empathy might avert Rwanda's shadow, reclaiming democracy's soul.